Iran war: Success or disaster? Mehdi Hasan and David Des Roches

play Live Sign upShow navigation menu.css-15ru6p1{font-size:inherit;font-weight:normal;}Navigation menuNewsShow more news sectionsAfricaAsiaUS & CanadaLatin AmericaEuropeAsia PacificWorld CupMiddle EastExplainedOpinionVideoMoreShow more sectionsFeaturesEconomySportHuman RightsClimate CrisisInvestigationsInteractivesIn PicturesScience & TechnologyPodcastsTravelSponsored Contentplay Live Click here to searchsearchSign upNavigation menucaret-leftTrendingUS-Israel war on IranWorld Cup 2026Tracking Israel's ceasefire violationsRussia-Ukraine warDonald Trumpcaret-rightplay videoplay videoVideo Duration 47 minutes 22 seconds play-arrow47:22Head to HeadIran war: Success or disaster? Mehdi Hasan and David Des RochesRead moreFollowing the US and Israeli airstrikes on Iran in February, reverberations were felt globally. But is the world really safer and Iranians freer or has the war unleashed disastrous consequences? Mehdi Hasan goes head to head with David Des Roches, retired colonel, former Pentagon official and professor at the National Defense University on the justifications and costs of the war – and whether President Donald Trump sent U.S. troops to fight Israel’s war. Joining the discussion are: Sanam Naraghi-Anderlini – founder and CEO of the International Civil Society Action Network Mohammad Ali Shabani – Middle East scholar and Editor of Amwaj.media, a London-based news outlet focused on Iran, Iraq and Arabian Peninsula countries Barak Seener – Associate Research Fellow, Henry Jackson Society Recorded shortly before the announcement of a deal between the US and Iran. xwhatsapp-strokecopylinkgoogleAdd Al Jazeera on GoogleinfoMore from the same showNigeria: ‘Renewed Hope’ or ‘Hopelessness’? | Mehdi Hasan and Daniel BwalaVideo Duration 49 minutes 30 seconds play-arrow49:30Who runs Venezuela now? Trump, oil and the fight for powerVideo Duration 50 minutes 20 seconds play-arrow50:20Behind the myths of the British Empire: Nigel Biggar and Mehdi HasanVideo Duration 51 minutes 50 seconds play-arrow51:50Is war between Ethiopia & Eritrea inevitable?: Mehdi Hasan & Getachew RedaVideo Duration 49 minutes 18 seconds play-arrow49:18Chainsaw economics, organ sales and governing by dog: Argentina under MileiVideo Duration 47 minutes 25 seconds play-arrow47:25Trump, Epstein and immigration raids: Mehdi Hasan and Mick MulvaneyVideo Duration 50 minutes 59 seconds play-arrow50:59Who is to blame for Sri Lanka’s crises?Video Duration 49 minutes 27 seconds play-arrow49:27AboutAboutShow moreAbout UsCode of EthicsTerms and ConditionsEU/EEA Regulatory NoticePrivacy PolicyCookie PolicyCookie PreferencesAccessibility StatementSitemapWork for usConnectConnectShow moreContact UsUser Accounts HelpAdvertise with usStay ConnectedNewslettersChannel FinderTV SchedulePodcastsSubmit a TipPaid Partner ContentOur ChannelsOur ChannelsShow moreAl Jazeera ArabicAl Jazeera EnglishAl Jazeera Investigative UnitAl Jazeera MubasherAl Jazeera DocumentaryAl Jazeera BalkansAJ+Our NetworkOur NetworkShow moreAl Jazeera Centre for StudiesAl Jazeera Media InstituteLearn ArabicAl Jazeera Centre for Public Liberties & Human RightsAl Jazeera ForumAl Jazeera Hotel PartnersFollow Al Jazeera English: