JONATHAN BROCKLEBANK: Move on from The Troubles? Swinney sounded like a child who thinks he can swim because he is wearing water wings

Published: 22:22, 14 May 2026 | Updated: 22:22, 14 May 2026 John Swinney and I were lucky. We grew up in the Scottish Lowlands, untroubled by war, untouched by terrorism. Our childhoods were free from the backdrop of dread which scarred others not so far away. Across the Border in England, for example, IRA bombs blew lives apart at regular intervals. The Birmingham pub bombings of 1974 killed 21. Another 12 died in the M62 coach bombing the same year. Harrods was bombed in 1983, the Grand Hotel, Brighton, in 1984. That was an attempt to assassinate Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher. Remember, Trade and Industry Secretary Norman Tebbit was gravely injured and his wife Margaret was left in a wheelchair for the rest of her days. Five died. In 1996, the biggest bomb detonated in the UK since the Second World War left more than 200 injured in Manchester city centre. The damage caused was equivalent to £1.3billion in today’s money. None of this carnage came to Scotland. John Swinney with the First Minister of Northern Ireland, Sinn Fein's Michelle O'Neill For John Swinney and me these were atrocities we heard about on the news, but we did not live them. We lost no one close to us. Across the Irish Sea, the effect on daily life of the IRA’s murderous campaign was many orders of magnitude more profound than in England. A childhood in Northern Ireland which coincided with The Troubles was one inevitably marked by trauma, by a shadow John Swinney and I, in our Scottish Lowland abodes, can scarcely imagine. It was inescapable. Every family knew victims. Many lost members of their own households. Well, Mr Swinney has a message for those who were less lucky than he and I were during those decades of bloodshed and horror: they should move on. And lest we suspect that he is a newbie to Northern Ireland politics, he wants people to know he wrote a dissertation on the subject as a student at Edinburgh University 40 years ago. ‘I looked at it very closely,’ he said in an interview this week. ‘I really do think people have got to move on.’ The reason the First Minister would prefer to view all this murder and mayhem as water under the bridge is he has recently been in dialogue with Michelle O’Neill, his opposite number in Northern Ireland and vice president of Sinn Fein since 2018. Sinn Fein, as Mr Swinney will be aware from his university course work, is historically regarded as the political wing of the IRA, which sought to achieve a united Ireland through terrorism. But, hey, forgive and forget. Or, as Mr Swinney would have it, ‘the world’s moved on’. It may be politically convenient for him to assume so. After all, he and Ms O’Neill and the new Welsh First Minister, Plaid Cymru’s Rhun ap Iorwerth, are on the same page in a manner of speaking. All want to rip their countries out of the UK. So Ms O’Neill’s party has historical ties with monsters who tried to bomb their way out of the UK, terrorist thugs wearing balaclavas and toting automatic weapons. The devastation in Manchester after the IRA bomb attack in 1996 So their methods were a little different back in the day. But it’s a bygone. Like I say, my childhood was as free from the shadow of terrorism as Mr Swinney’s was, but I squirmed with embarrassment when I heard him deploy his 1986 undergraduate essay as evidence of insight. He sounded like a little boy who thinks his water wings make him a real swimmer. If that was my reaction, how might those whose lives were destroyed by the campaign of violence respond to the suggestion that he’s up on his Troubles history because he wrote about it once as a student? Among the dead were Scottish soldiers. Ayrshire brothers John and Joseph McCaig, aged 17 and 18, and Dougald McCaughey, 23, from Glasgow, were lured from a Belfast pub and executed by the IRA in 1971. No one was ever arrested for their murders. Last year Dougald’s cousin David described the atrocity as ‘a scar that never healed and never will’. He and his family still press for answers 55 years later. John Swinney reckons they should move on. What he misses is that The Troubles are not a finite event. They are woven into the collective psyche of those who endured them, whose lives have been shaped by them, who daily count the emotional cost. Their healing does not happen at Mr Swinney’s political convenience. It is the lived experience of those people – still suffering, still working through their trauma – which weighs more heavily with me than a student essay Scotland’s First Minister wrote in 1986. Move on, he says. John Swinney, of all people. We had a referendum in Scotland back in 2014. No one died. There were no bombings or shootings or kneecappings, no mischief to challenge the human soul’s powers of recovery. The people went to the polls and delivered their verdict: Scotland should remain in the UK. It was, we were assured by Mr Swinney’s party, a once in a generation – even ‘once in a lifetime’ – vote. It didn’t go his way. Still, we move on from life’s disappointments, don’t we? No sense in letting grievances fester when the matter was settled fair and square. Oh, the supreme irony – a Scottish First Minister urging others to move on from experiences more searing than any his land has known in modern times, when moving on is precisely what his party is singularly incapable of doing. Indeed, the SNP’s whole schtick is a refusal to move on, however badly Scotland needs it to do so. Every area of devolved power – education, health, transport, you name it – runs a poor second to its obsession with fighting a battle which is already lost. Moving on? Scotland has not been granted a single day of this since 2014. Ours is a land whose wheels spin endlessly in the mud, digging ever deeper trenches, making forward motion an ever less feasible prospect. The IRA bombed the Grand Hotel in Brighton in 1984 in a bid to murder Margaret Thatcher Attainment gaps widen, waiting lists lengthen, the economy tanks but the SNP soldiers on in government because its policy of wallowing in a lost constitutional crusade absolves the party of every failure in the eyes of a sizeable enough rump of the electorate. So much for Mr Swinney’s explanation for dealing with Sinn Fein. The world has moved on. People should too, even if he is Scotland’s poster boy for not letting things go. Have you heard a coherent explanation yet for his refusal to deal with politicians rather closer to hand, namely the 17 democratically elected Reform MSPs who were yesterday sworn in at the Scottish parliament? I don’t recall any Reform bombing campaigns. They laid out their prospectus for change, same as everyone else, and proved the breakthrough party of the Scottish election. The First Minister lets it be known he will have nothing to do with them. What kind of message does that send to the thousands of Scots who voted for Reform? That he’ll have no truck with them either? So this is what governing for all of Scotland looks like. Dialogue with Sinn Fein over the water, the door slammed in the face of Reform at home, and a sense that policy is decided in a paddling pool – by a man in water wings. No comments have so far been submitted. Why not be the first to send us your thoughts, or debate this issue live on our message boards. By posting your comment you agree to our house rules. Do you want to automatically post your MailOnline comments to your Facebook Timeline? Your comment will be posted to MailOnline as usual. Do you want to automatically post your MailOnline comments to your Facebook Timeline? Your comment will be posted to MailOnline as usual We will automatically post your comment and a link to the news story to your Facebook timeline at the same time it is posted on MailOnline. To do this we will link your MailOnline account with your Facebook account. We’ll ask you to confirm this for your first post to Facebook. You can choose on each post whether you would like it to be posted to Facebook. Your details from Facebook will be used to provide you with tailored content, marketing and ads in line with our Privacy Policy.