DOJ finds EEOC violated law by pressuring employers to make race-based decisions

Politics DOJ finds EEOC violated civil rights laws with guidelines that pressured employers to make race-based decisions By Sarah N. Lynch Sarah N. Lynch Senior Justice Department Reporter Sarah N. Lynch is the senior Justice Department reporter for CBS News, based in Washington, D.C. Read Full Bio Sarah N. Lynch Updated on: June 9, 2026 / 12:02 PM EDT / CBS News Add CBS News on Google Washington — The Justice Department on Tuesday accused the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission of violating federal civil rights laws by issuing guidelines that effectively pressured employers to make race-based considerations in hiring and promotions.A new legal opinion by the Office of Legal Counsel claimed that "disparate impact" — a legal theory of discrimination that holds employers liable for discrimination for policies that disproportionately harm protected groups based on race, ethnicity or gender — is unconstitutional."The fundamental problem is that disparate-impact liability tends to incent — and even coerce — employers to make race-based decisions to avoid liability or the threat of liability," said the opinion, which was signed by OLC Assistant Attorney General T. Elliot Gaiser and OLC Deputy Assistant Attorney General Joshua Craddock.Although the opinion does not hold the same legal weight as a court ruling, it will likely make it more challenging for employees who file employment discrimination claims with the EEOC to prevail.The Justice Department said that going forward, employers can use tools such as aptitude tests, criminal background checks and other metrics without fear that they could face discrimination claims based solely on the impact those tools may have on different demographic groups."Despite trying to promote equality, EEOC's disparate impact liability interpretation under Title VII actually fosters the very discrimination its guidelines seek to address," said Acting Attorney General Todd Blanche, who was formally nominat...